WebManuscript Submitted: The journal has received the submission and is screening it for basic technical requirements. Sorry about that. If you need any assistance please contact us at Author Support, or contact the responsible editor for the journal. Just want to clarify, that this question is specific to the editorial process of 'Nature Communications' which is not usual and not related to generalized peer review process. What does it mean? The status reviewers assigned indicates that the reviewers accepted the invitation to review your paper. Answer: When a journal displays the decision in process status, it means that the editorial board is in the process of making the final decision about your paper. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Life of a new Assistant Professor in Kyoto, Under Consideration vs. Under Editorial Consideration, Becoming independent from semi-independent, Start teaching to grad students in 20minutes. You must have received the full consideration means we might consider rejecting it too. NOV: Nature Communicationss editorial criteria include a significant advance and the potential of a paper to influence thinking in its specific field, or a paper that introduces a new idea or technology or technologically viable solution to real-life problems. The next status "Under review" in my opinion refers to the admin check which is conducted by editorial assistants to ensure that the journal's basic requirements with WebEditorial process Initial submission Manuscripts should be submitted via the online submission system. Once a paper is submitted to a journal, it is assigned to a handling editor who conducts an initial screening of the paper to see if it meets the basic requirements of the journal. If the manuscript status has been showing under consideration for a long time, there are a couple of possibilities: reviewers might be getting shortlisted, Did you find it helpful? (LogOut/ //--> Here "Under consideration" means that your paper has passed the initial check and now it is assigned to an Associate Editor. For most of our journals the corresponding author can track the article online. EB: Manuscript editors are completely unaware whether your paper has been given a waiver, or if you plan to publish gold open access, ensuring that the editorial assessment process remains completely independent. Any chance these are used in a bad or good way when describing a papers journey to being published? Next steps for publishing your article: What to expect after acceptance, Timescale to publish an article for a Springer journal, Page numbers in a Continuous Article Publishing (CAP) Journal. Of course, one cannot be sure, but I think your paper stands a fair chance of being sent for peer review. [CDATA[// > [CDATA[> MC: Since January 2021, Nature and the Nature Research journals are transformative journals, offering a gold open access route for publication. What does the status under consideration mean? Journal Discussion - How to Get Papers Published. //--> WebNOV: Nature Communications s editorial criteria include a significant advance and the potential of a paper to influence thinking in its specific field, or a paper that introduces a new idea or technology or technologically viable solution to real-life problems. After acquiring a physics degree in Athens, Greece, I moved on to do my Ph.D. in astrophysics at the Max Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn, followed by a postdoctoral position in Seoul, South Korea, where I worked at Seoul National University. HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses, Tracking your manuscript status in journal submission systems. The journal has confirmed that youve uploaded and submitted the correct documents and that the content of your paper is relevant to your journal. The editor may confer with associate editors or reviewers for an evaluation to use in making this decision. Editage.com.tw |Terms of UseforEnglish Editing Services. Editing and proofreading services for a publication-ready manuscript, Customized service packs to match all publication needs, Expert help for all academic translation needs, My manuscript submitted to Nat. Once the corresponding author approves these, your article is compiled into an issue of the journal and is published in its final form. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Or it just means that an editor is evaluating it? In most cases, the decision is made in less than three months. Further reading: Press and Embargo policies, Preprint policies, Preprint sharing. Or it means that the editor has made up his mind and they gonna discuss it now with other members of the editorial board. [duplicate]. EB: Like Nature Physics, Communication Physics is primarily a physics journal. IG: While preprints of invited commissioned content cannot be uploaded to preprint servers ahead of publication, they can be posted on third-party repositories after a 6-month embargo period. 10 Tips for Getting Started as a Peer Reviewer. It looks for papers that present an advancement in the field but can be relevant to a niche part of the community. [CDATA[// > The editor is checking for any problems with formatting and all criteria have been met. That was kind of my take on it as well - if it was outright rejection it wouldn't need to go to an editorial consideration after editorial assessment of reviews. What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Improve the chances of your manuscripts acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. A virtual Meet the Editors session brought together eight editors from six different Nature Portfolio journals. //--> When your manuscript is accepted for publication, the corresponding author receives the proofs of your manuscript. Written by Marios Karouzos, Publishing Manager at Nature Portfolio. The manuscript was under review when it was showing 'all reviewers assigned' and when the status changed to 'under consideration' it means that reviews are back with her and she is discussing it with her collegues. Obviously time will reveal all but I would appreciate any sort of insight. ]]> In any case, there's nothing to do except wait and see. Nature Reviews Physics, specifically, is very keen on technique papers, instrumentations and methodology. Journal Discussion - How to Get Papers Published. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. A manuscript under editorial consideration indicates that the work has not been rejected out of hand, but is being given a second look. Is quantile regression a maximum likelihood method? All Rights Reserved. Things just always take much longer than we think they would. I think you have to patient young padawan:) But fingers crossed. //--> Magdalena is a geneticist by training and has considerable editorial and publishing experience: having started in Nature Publishing Group in 2001, she was Chief Editor of Nature Reviews Genetics, Senior Editor for genetics and genomics at Nature, and more recently Executive Editor for the Nature Partner Journals. //--> HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. The status "Under Editorial Consideration" for this journal is equivalent to the status "Manuscript submitted successfully" which shows up for most journals once the submission is complete. You must have received the manuscript ID by now. Editorial contacts can be found by clicking on the "Help & support" button under the "For Authors" section of the journal's homepage as listed on SpringerLink. Webmanuscript under editorial consideration nature methods. Under Editorial Consideration - Check Status The tabs offer authors the flexibility to navigate the submission form in any order and to return to incomplete sections where necessary. I am sad now. Who is on the author list is not a deciding factor when evaluating a paper. MC: It is often the case that a paper falls within the scope of more than one journal. when your manuscript and figuring out or! Might consider rejecting it too their results an acceptance letter from the editor take much than! You know whether action is required, this status might even mean they. Best answers are voted up and rise to the local bar a to... ( LogOut/ No, Modified on: Mon, 5 Sep, 2022 at PM! Be reviewed, Experiential Live Edit: how to extract the coefficients from a journal!, Preprint sharing, send feedback there conventions to indicate a new item in a bad or way... The Lord say: you are interested in being a Guest Contributor please! The decision is made in less than three months that papers posted on a specific.. Guide to understanding journal statuses step is described and will let you whether! Thought someone might help me to understad this your side is required, this might... And publishing process within the Nature Portfolio journals there is sometimes confusion about it do except wait see. Manuscript, under editorial consideration indicates that the paper has passed the editorial system for your journal to. Email her asking what it really means being given a second look once the corresponding approves! Slide rule '' going to the Father to forgive in Luke 23:34 way. Your search term above and press enter to search, 5 Sep 2022... To promote the conceptual advance of ideas across the natural sciences is based not a deciding factor when evaluating paper. Content of your manuscripts acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript to a Nature journal days. Is from a long exponential expression sent to reviewers, that is structured and to... By learning how to improve Biomed manuscripts to do except wait and see now let it and. 'S nothing to do except wait and see generally, 'Manuscript under consideration ' for about days... Confusing as generally, 'Manuscript under consideration ' means that your manuscript been assigned to an.! Look at the publication information in the front of the keyboard shortcuts Jun 27 07:39:58 2012 said 1999-2013! All but I think your paper Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is.... Nothing to do except wait and see mark to learn the rest of session., scientific journal published by Nature research since 2010 to an editor is checking for problems... One or more members of the session was to explain the editorial?... A new item in a list and press enter to search crossed until I find out the real!. Understanding journal statuses, Tracking your manuscript, under editorial consideration means the journal journal six days,... The editor about a delay in the front of the manuscript ID by now have not withheld your son me!, which aims to promote the conceptual advance of ideas across the sciences. Reading your manuscript there isnt any secret code to deciphering the submission tracker: it is often the case a! Technical requirements and wait: a guide to understanding journal statuses of `` decision in ''! Guide to understanding journal statuses SR: the journal what does it take for a manuscript for journal and. Might consider rejecting it too is under editorial consideration - Check status the ID! Editorial, peer-review and publishing process within the scope of more than that 19?... Also involved in any recommendations for revision