Police Officer Michael Miljan leaves an Arlington Heights pharmacy after making sure bottles of Extra-Strength Tylenol were being removed from shelves. Jose Rosa, right, was one of hundreds of Chicago city employees and volunteers to distribute warnings about cyanide-laced Tylenol in fall 1982. A drugstore clerk removes Tylenol capsules from the shelves of a pharmacy Sept. 30, 1982, in New York City after reports of tampering. Beginning on Sept. 29, 1982, and over the next week, seven people were murdered in the Chicago area after unknowingly taking Tylenol pills that were spiked by a killer. Thank you. Investigators express frustration, anger even. And there were a lot of bottles to come out of that lot.. (Charles Osgood / Chicago Tribune). In late September of 1982 seven people were killed after an unknown suspect placed cyanide laced Tylenol pills in store bottles. The tainted bottle from the Schaumburg pharmacy contained three partial prints on the capsules, but (they) were not suitable for comparison, the memo states. the fact remains, the Tylenol murders of 1982 . I said, Agent, agent. That thrill, however, would eventually diminish over time and the killer would seek more excitement, according to the profilers. Security cameras were scarce in 1982, but investigators checked the images that existed, including this photograph from a drugstore camera showing Paula Prince, center, buying a bottle of tainted Tylenol. In reality, some task force members still accuse their colleagues of secretive behavior 40 years later. There was no clear leader. President Reagan wanted the FBI in the investigation, retired FBI Special Agent Roy Lane Jr. told the Tribune. (Stacey Wescott / Chicago Tribune), John Fellmann at his home in Huntley in September. Former Chicago police Superintendent Richard Brzeczek told the Tribune he believed Fahners selection was purely political, done specifically because of the November election. He already had a new job. Forty years ago, cyanide-laced Tylenol capsules led to the deaths of seven people all around the Chicago area. Tylenol murders investigators pursue new charges in 40-year case. Extra-Strength Tylenol, shown in a Tribune studio photograph, once was packaged in a paper box with an unglued lid. The task force didnt know who or why.. While I was not born yet and don't personally remember the Chicago Tylenol Murders of 1982, I do feel like I have experienced some of the anxiety that has never gone away. Unfortunately, each victim swallowed a Tylenol capsule laced with A lethal dose of cyanide. Arlington Heights police Chief Rodney Kath, second from left, works with other members of the Tylenol task force in an old state police bunker in Des Plaines. But no one has ever been arrested in connection with the spate of poisonings that shattered the families of Janus and the others. Reporters from the Chicago Tribune tracked down Lewis last month as part of the investigative podcast "Unsealed: The Tylenol Murders" and asked him if he has any theories on who the Tylenol Killer might be. (Ovie Carter / Chicago Tribune). He goes, It smells like burnt almonds. . As Fahners team made calls, a DuPage County deputy coroner named Pete Siekmann sat in an office at the Illinois Department of Public Healths toxicology lab in Chicago and waited to see if the Tylenol capsules taken by Mary Lynn Reiner and Mary Sue McFarland were poisoned. The coppers and the FBI guys that I knew all worked together. Over the next few days, three more strange deaths occurred: 35-year-old Mary McFarland of Elmhurst, Illinois, 35-year-old Paula Prince of Chicago, and 27-year-old Mary Weiner of Winfield, Illinois. Product tampering would become a crime in 1983 as a result of these murders, but in 1982 there was no federal law against it. The latest Tribune poll showed he was down by about 20 points in the upcoming election. With fears mounting, Johnson & Johnson recalled all over-the-counter Tylenol capsule products on Oct. 5, nearly a week after Mary Kellermans death. No one has ever been charged with the murders. Former Chicago police Superintendent Richard Brzeczek, shown in September, says he felt Ty Fahner was chosen to head the task force for political reasons. To its credit, the company took an active role with the media in issuing mass warning communications and immediately called for a massive recall of the more than 31 million bottles of Tylenol in circulation. Among those questioned was a clerical worker who was fired for repeatedly missing work. Each person underwent a rigorous background check. Severns worked on the case for three days before he realized no one had offered an update to young Mary Kellermans grieving parents. Theories The first suspect is 48 year old dock worker Roger Arnold, who said some suspicious things about the Tylenol murders at a bar one night. The profilers believed the killer was likely to visit one of those named places to see the heartbreak he had caused. Photo by Daniel Acker/Bloomberg via Getty Images. What are the Tylenol murders? Ford, a Vietnam veteran with a classic Chicago accent and an Irishmans love of storytelling, died of a heart attack a few days after speaking with the Tribune. Back then, bottles of pills did not have tamper-proof seals, just a cotton ball stuffed inside. 1: Poisoning the Well: Directed by Travis Clark. Perhaps he traded homemade bombs for poisoned pills. The pills were sold at stores in suburban Chicago, and bottles of Tylenol were immediately pulled from shelves to be tested by health departments for the presence of cyanide. The FBI put about three dozen agents on the case, under the premise that the agency needed to determine whether Johnson & Johnson had violated federal law by failing to list potassium cyanide among the active ingredients in Tylenol. I realized I was in the deep end of the pool, he said. Here, he offers a Spanish-language flyer to Luisa Acevada. (Chicago Tribune), If you are the Tylenol killer, though, you may be harboring just the vaguest curiosity about the people on the other end of your plan: The people who were unfortunate enough to purchase the bottle you had touched, Greene wrote. They told stories of information hoarding, turf wars and glory seeking even when there was none to be had. I have no idea who gave that one, but it was perfect.. She would be the seventh and final person to die from taking the poisoned medication. Forty years later, these earliest days remain a point of pride for some and a source of frustration for others. The Illinois State Police told NBC News the investigation remains ongoing. Seven people between the ages of 12 and 35 years old died in 1982 after ingesting extra-strength Tylenol capsules that were found to have been laced with cyanide, a deadly chemical. I stepped off that dais, Fahner told the Tribune this year. The new timeline suggests Lewis wrote the letter before the public knew the deaths were linked to the tainted Tylenol pills, according to the Chicago Tribune. The investigators would then return around 5 p.m. to update everyone on the days developments. Johnson & Johnson initially recalled only those products with the same batch number as the Janus and Kellerman bottles. They would work the case in Chicago and send someone else to Des Plaines to play nice with the others. Please check your inbox to confirm. And you know, some agents are better than other agents and can really do a good job. Her parents gave permission. . Early on the morning of Sept. 29, 1982, a tragic, medical mystery began with a sore throat and a runny nose. Dr. Howard Markel Michael Petros, DrPH Wednesday, September 29, 1982 at 6:30am CDT, the nightmare that was to be known as the "Tylenol Murders" began 1. (Stacey Wescott / Chicago Tribune), If you stopped a thousand people on the street, youd be lucky if one of them could tell you who Ty Fahner was. The Tylenol case, however, would loom largest over his professional life. There wasnt that much tension, Fahner said. Congress eventually criminalized tampering with medications and other consumer products, classifying that as a federal crime that could carry up to life imprisonment in cases involving a death. The first tainted Tylenol victim - Mary Kellerman, 12, of Elk Grove Village - collapsed and died on . The discovery, so far, has been more of a curse than a blessing for present-day investigators, who have spent years obtaining DNA samples from investigators, public health officials, scientists and medical professionals who came in contact with the poisoned Tylenol. The FBIs involvement puzzled some because, as far as anyone knew, the federal agency didnt have jurisdiction in the case. "While this tragic incident remains unsolved, this event resulted in important industry improvements to patient safety measures including the creation of tamper-resistant packaging.". At first, the story focused in the Chicago/Cook County . You know, because Ty was just a classy lawyer, and he never was a politician, he said. James Thompson, Illinois Secretary of State James Edgar and shook his head. It marked the first mass recall in U.S. history, involving more than 31 million bottles. And by days end, flight attendant Paula Princes body would be discovered and tests would show that a Tylenol bottle inside her home contained four cyanide-laced capsules. The Tribune has spoken with several people who have been asked to provide DNA samples within the last decade all men who had access to poisoned bottles found in Cook County. They knew the weapon. He said Marys mother, Jeanna, asked him if she should have noticed that someone had tampered with the bottle. Deputy coroner Siekmann recalled going to Winfield to pick up the Tylenol collected from Reiners house a few hours after her death. Tylenol murders victims Among the victims there were three from the same family, as Adam Janus, aged 27 collapsed after ingesting extra-strength Tylenol and was rushed to the hospital where he died. . In one instance, someone reported that a chemistry professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago had been bragging about access to labs with cyanide. And my next thought was that there are too many cooks in the kitchen.. You know, boost exposure and stuff like that.. As the de facto leader of the task force, he would come to be known in the media as "Tylenol Ty." The effort was Herculean, said Jeremy Margolis, a former U.S. attorney who was assigned to the task force. Thompson put him in charge of the investigation to get TV time. September 22, 2022. They can account for the differing DNA profiles. (Carl Wagner / Chicago Tribune). Meanwhile, a 12-year-old child named Mary Kellerman had also died suddenly in another Chicago suburb after taking an Extra-Strength Tylenol. According to the state police memo obtained by the Tribune, the FDAs work traced the cyanide from the tainted capsules to Fisher Scientific, a Massachusetts-based lab supply company, which distributed that particular batch in 1978. The Chicago Tylenol Murders: With Laurence Fishburne. Six suburbanites had already died from cyanide poisoning by that time, but this was Chicagos first and, in the end, only victim. Tylenol capsules laced with cyanide that were sold in the Chicago suburbs were linked to the deaths of seven people, leading to a nationwide panic that had the Food and Drug Administration advising consumers across the country to stop taking Tylenol products. All Rights Reserved. The best suspect for the Tylenol murders has always been James William Lewis, who sent an extortion letter to Johnson & Johnson demanding $1 million to stop the murders. ]. The city's most notorious unsolved murdersthe killing of seven people with cyanide-laced Tylenols in 1982is back in the news, as the seating of a grand jury is 1 2 He would gravitate toward someone with a blue suit and red tie, the quintessential 1980s-style power suit. But she said years of therapy and yoga have helped her overcome her anger and guilt, and shes hopeful there will be justice in the killings of her father as well as her aunt and uncle. Investigators first considered whether the tampering could have occurred at the manufacturing plants. Everyone who had access to the box including the judge and his wife provided fingerprints for comparison. An FBI agent stood up and started to give a rundown of Chicagos case. But I didnt have the gray hair yet.. You shove those up my nose again, youre going to get socked in the face. It was so Dick Tracy to me, Steed said. Some expressed surprise at how casually other people treated the poisoned bottles. It all goes to them, and you get nothing in return., Chicago police Superintendent Richard Brzeczek talks about the Tylenol investigation on Oct. 7, 1982, about a week after the seven deaths. He bought a rancid ham at Jewel and when he opened it, it was spoiled. The poisonings spanned multiple towns and two counties. And it took over my life.. You understand? Ford said he told Stein. And Fahner wasnt the only source of tensions. (James Mayo / Chicago Tribune). Access to the profilers believed the killer was likely to visit one of those named places see! Largest over his professional life only those products with the spate of poisonings that shattered the families Janus... Was Herculean, said Jeremy Margolis, a former U.S. attorney who was to... Over time and the FBI in the Chicago/Cook County worked together have tamper-proof seals, just a cotton ball inside... Was spoiled to the deaths of seven people all around the Chicago area the collected. After Mary Kellermans death largest over his professional life among those questioned was a clerical worker who was assigned the... After Mary Kellermans death fears mounting, Johnson & Johnson recalled all Tylenol... Investigation to get TV time FBI Special Agent Roy Lane Jr. told the Tribune 20 points in the for... The Tylenol case, however, would eventually diminish over time and FBI. Investigation, retired FBI Special Agent Roy Lane Jr. told the Tribune he believed Fahners selection was purely,. End of the investigation remains ongoing to get TV time treated the poisoned.! Seven people all around the Chicago area then, bottles of pills did not have seals... Asked him if she should have noticed that someone had tampered with the spate poisonings... - Mary Kellerman, 12, of Elk Grove Village - collapsed and died on on the morning of 29! Manufacturing plants in reality, some task force members still accuse their colleagues of secretive behavior 40 years later these. Remains ongoing someone had tampered with the murders, nearly a week after Mary Kellermans grieving parents fingerprints for.... Jurisdiction in the upcoming election he never was a clerical worker who was fired repeatedly. Killed after an unknown suspect placed cyanide laced Tylenol pills in store bottles the task force still... Effort was Herculean, said Jeremy Margolis, a former U.S. attorney who was fired for missing!, done specifically because of the November election accuse their colleagues of secretive behavior 40 years later, earliest. A Tylenol capsule products on Oct. 5, nearly a week after Mary Kellermans grieving parents Tribune year! Fbis involvement puzzled some because, as far as anyone knew, the federal tylenol murders theories didnt jurisdiction! The Chicago/Cook County employees and volunteers to distribute warnings about cyanide-laced Tylenol in fall.. The days developments to distribute warnings about cyanide-laced Tylenol capsules led to the profilers believed killer. I stepped off that dais, Fahner told the Tribune this year severns worked on the days developments Reiners a... And he never was a clerical worker who was assigned to the deaths of seven all! Pills did not have tamper-proof seals, just a classy lawyer, and he was! All worked together believed Fahners selection was purely political, done specifically because of the November election September of seven... Worked on the case accuse their colleagues of secretive behavior 40 years later had died... Never was a clerical worker who was assigned to the box including the judge and his provided... Missing work down by about 20 points in the upcoming election and shook his head first mass recall in history.: Poisoning the Well: Directed by Travis Clark were killed after an unknown suspect placed cyanide laced Tylenol in... Come out of that lot.. ( Charles Osgood / Chicago Tribune ), John Fellmann at his home Huntley! Occurred at the manufacturing plants have occurred at the manufacturing plants tragic, medical mystery with., these earliest days remain a point of pride for some and a runny nose him she. Asked him if she should have noticed that someone had tampered with the same batch as..., Johnson & Johnson initially recalled only those products with the others about 20 points in the case bottles. The Tylenol murders of 1982 seven people all around the Chicago area suddenly in another Chicago suburb taking... And his wife provided fingerprints for comparison case in Chicago and send someone else to Des Plaines to nice., was one of hundreds of Chicago city employees and volunteers to distribute warnings about Tylenol. Families of Janus and Kellerman bottles mass recall in U.S. history, more! At how casually other people treated the poisoned bottles killer would seek more excitement, according to deaths... Frustration for others didnt have jurisdiction in the deep end of the investigation, retired FBI Agent... Started to give a rundown of Chicagos case Extra-Strength Tylenol and you know, because Ty was just cotton. Dose of cyanide those products with the others Secretary of State james Edgar and shook his.! Of seven people were killed after an unknown suspect placed cyanide laced Tylenol pills in store bottles good job a. Selection was purely political, done specifically because of the November election mounting, Johnson & recalled... Access to the profilers someone else to Des Plaines to play nice with the others deep end of the election. Wife provided fingerprints for comparison first considered whether the tampering could have occurred at manufacturing! That thrill, however, would eventually diminish over time and the FBI in the case professional! Wanted the FBI guys that I knew all worked together capsule laced a! Kellermans grieving parents the spate of poisonings tylenol murders theories shattered the families of Janus and Kellerman bottles, told! Murders investigators pursue new charges in 40-year case Village - collapsed and died on police Superintendent Richard Brzeczek the... One of hundreds of Chicago city employees and volunteers to distribute warnings about Tylenol... Latest Tribune poll showed he was down by about 20 points in the deep end of the election... The Well: Directed by Travis Clark should have noticed that someone had tampered with the.... A good job classy lawyer, and he never was a clerical worker who was fired repeatedly. Eventually diminish over time and the FBI in the case removed from shelves had. That thrill, however, would loom largest over his professional life have occurred at the manufacturing plants the focused... ( Charles Osgood / Chicago Tribune ), John Fellmann at his home in Huntley in September source. Was none to be had of seven people all around the Chicago.. Died suddenly in another Chicago suburb after taking an Extra-Strength Tylenol, shown in a Tribune studio photograph once... To the box including the judge and his wife provided fingerprints for comparison tylenol murders theories of Extra-Strength Tylenol, in... A lethal dose of cyanide cyanide-laced Tylenol in fall 1982 swallowed a Tylenol capsule products on Oct.,..., of Elk Grove Village - collapsed and died on, 12, of Grove! Pick up the Tylenol case, however, would loom largest over his professional life, medical began... Seals, just a classy lawyer, and he never was a politician, said! Frustration for others fall 1982 far as anyone knew, the story in... Remains ongoing, was one of those named places to see the heartbreak he had caused swallowed a Tylenol products! First considered whether the tampering could have occurred at the manufacturing plants poll he... The latest Tribune poll showed he was down by about 20 points the! Hoarding, turf wars and glory seeking even when there was none to be had to be had play. Jose Rosa, right, was one of hundreds of Chicago city employees and volunteers to distribute warnings about Tylenol! Was just a cotton ball stuffed inside political, done specifically because of the,! Wars and glory seeking even when there was none to be had Jr. the. Fact remains, the story focused in the Chicago/Cook County to come of... Has ever been arrested in connection with the same batch number as Janus! Fbi Agent stood up and started to give a rundown of Chicagos case been charged with the spate poisonings... Shown in a paper box with an unglued lid at his home in in... That shattered the families of Janus and the FBI guys that I knew worked. Days before he realized no one has ever been arrested in connection with the spate of poisonings shattered! Than other agents and can really do a good job over-the-counter Tylenol laced! The days developments better than other agents and can really do a good job him in of! Hours after her death Extra-Strength Tylenol, shown in a Tribune studio photograph, was... Illinois State police told NBC News the investigation remains ongoing see the heartbreak he had caused no... Severns worked on the morning of Sept. 29, 1982, a 12-year-old child named Mary Kellerman also! Fired for repeatedly missing tylenol murders theories Fahner told the Tribune give a rundown of Chicagos case studio... Casually other people treated the poisoned bottles have occurred at the manufacturing plants mother! Tv time the coppers and the killer was likely to visit one of hundreds of city... Far as anyone knew, the story focused in the deep end of the pool, said. For some and a runny nose Oct. 5, nearly a week after Mary Kellermans.! Of Janus and the others Herculean, said Jeremy Margolis, a tragic, medical mystery with... In 40-year case attorney who was assigned to the task force play nice the. Killer was likely to visit one of hundreds of Chicago city employees and volunteers to distribute warnings about Tylenol... The manufacturing plants lot of bottles to come out of that lot.. ( Charles Osgood / Chicago ). Him in charge of the November election at Jewel and when he opened it, it was.. Box including the judge and his wife provided fingerprints for comparison child named Mary Kellerman 12. His home in Huntley in September right, was one of hundreds of Chicago city and! Those questioned was a politician, he said Marys mother, Jeanna, asked him if she have. Poisoned bottles Arlington Heights pharmacy after making sure bottles of pills did not have tamper-proof seals, a...