But if Mark chose his mother to call, over all other people in the world, would he be likely to make such a mistake? from 8 AM - 9 PM ET. A key element of the transcript is particularly questionable. As I have pointed out elsewhere, cellphone calls from commercial aircraft much over 8000 feet are essentially impossible, while those below 8000 feet are highly unlikely down to about 2000, where they become merely unlikely. pp. But in theinterviews she gaveand the official reports about her call with Beamer, there is nothing to indicate that Jefferson posed that question. Minutes before United Airlines Flight 93 crashed in an empty field in Pennsylvania, passengers and crew members aboard the plane made dozens of phone calls to people on the ground, alerting them that the jetliner was hijacked by terrorists. Flight 93's passengers and crew decide to storm the cockpit. (Fraizer, 2002) Fraizer J. The tape ends at 10:03 as the plane nose-dives at an estimated 580 mph into a reclaimed coal field near Shanksville, Pennsylvania, about 80 miles from Pittsburgh. And in the wake of Sept. 11, Oracle is counting on the heightened interest in staving off terrorism to boost its government ties even more. We are in the air. 2001. Near the end of this conversation, when the caller discusses possible actions against the hijackers, he makes a joking remark: This is strange because it implies that the caller had already finished breakfast, whereas meals are not normally served until the aircraft reaches cruising altitude, about the time that the alleged hijacking began. As a supervisor, [Jefferson] would have been the one to monitor the taping, but she did not want to risk losing the call." WashingtonPost.Com. As shown in documents uploaded by the 9/11 Document Archive on Scribd run by Kevin Fenton, the author of "Disconnecting the Dots: How 9/11 Was Allowed to Happen," the transcripts referenced include Jeffersons own recollections, and recordings of conversations between Jefferson and Lisa Beamer, Todds widow. READ NEXT: Jim Bakker 2021: Where Is the Televangelist Today? Sometimes questions themselves are suggestive. Firm's growth sustained as niche established with federal, state agencies ", U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, March 1, 2006, p. 11, Jim McKinnon, "GTE Operator Connects With, Uplifts Widow of Hero in Hijacking. Those notes are in the FBI's possession. [7] She told Beamer's wife: "If I hadn't known it was a real hijacking, I'd have thought it was a crank call, because Todd was so rational and methodical about what he was doing." At about this time the takedown would have been initiated. Barbara Olson, a well-known Washington lawyer and, more recently, television political pundit, died aboard American Airlines Flight 77, the aircraft which reportedly struck the Pentagon building. Flight 93: Forty lives, one destiny. Image Via Stephenwissink/Wikimedia Commons, Disconnecting the Dots: How 9/11 Was Allowed to Happen. "The Transcript from Flight 93" Eternity News. Agents taking the flight on several occasions prior to September 11 would have an ample opportunity to engage numerous fellow passengers in chitchat, meanwhile recording their voices. The caller seemed to know at least a few personal details about the person being called. I don't want to die," she repeats. The flight had been delayed for 43 minutes due to heavy air traffic. [3] Yet, an examination of Todd Beamer's phone call reveals numerous oddities, coincidences, and seeming impossibilities. Strangely enough, caller D preferred to talk to Lisa Jefferson (asking her to call his loved ones for him), even though he was about to die. Ive got to go. Lisa: Todd..I have to tell you the truth..its very bad. First, it must be noted that the longest call was made by the person who identified himself as Todd Beamer (Call D) to someone whom the real Todd Beamer did not know at all, Lisa Jefferson, a Verizon supervisor. Alice Bingham attributed the strange introductory sentence to her son being flustered. Sherman McCoy (@wasphyxiation) September 11, 2021. The only hard conclusion I come to is that there is a need for a proper investigation of the Todd Beamer phone call. Will not be sharing a where were you on 9/11 bc if youre my age youll have the same story. "The World Trade Center is gone," Jefferson purportedly tells Beamer in the post. The conversation was never recorded and an actual transcript does not exist. Larry Ellison, boss of Oracle, the company Todd worked for, had spun the story of Todd the hero aboard Flight 93 on Thursday, before anyone else knew of Todd's phone call. What did Larry Ellison have to do with it? [18]. For example, inaCBS interview, Jefferson describes how she and Beamer prayed together, and linesof supposed dialogue in the postportray them doing that. Thinking that far ahead was too frightening, too painful, too overwhelming to consider, she wrote, according to the article. 9/11 Audio Recordings Offer Dramatic Timeline . "Please sit down, keep remaining seating. This fake transcript is accurate in some instances, particularly when using Jeffersons and numerous media accounts of Beamers very last words, which were Lets roll. At that point he and other passengers were about to try to take back the flight from the hijackers. Still, the supposed conversation in the post takescreative license, andmany of the details are untrue. One by one, in a rapid cascade that would last only seconds, all the channels would be closed, leading to a network-wide breakdown. Todd Beamer (1968 - 2001) was a passenger on United Airlines Flight 93 when it was hijacked on September 11th 2001. Finally, although the FBI conducted a massive investigation into the calls, none of the telephone billing, nor any of the cell phone location data stored in standard phone company records has been publicly released. (Yet how long does it take to review a written summary of a 13-minute phone call?) The second GTE/Airfone operator said she could hear screams, prayers, exclamations, and talk of subduing the highjackers At approximately 9 am CST (10 am EST), Beamer said that the passengers were about to attack the highjackers.". ), making the basis for those questions easy fodder for attacks like these --, "Hey, you know what, David? [16]), The question remains: If Todd Beamer really did not want to talk to his wife because she was pregnant and he was afraid he might upset her, why had be been trying to phone her in the first place? It was at the end of this call that Beamer was heard declaring: "Let's roll," before joining a passenger revolt against the terrorists. Okay. In a second attempt, the caller described men with boxcutters overpowering the flight crew, then asked, What do I tell the pilot to do?. LETS ROLL. For evil to triumph it only takes good men doing nothing. ", Glen Johnson, "Probe Reconstructs Horror, Calculated Attacks on Planes. Jarrah makes a hard turn to the left, banking the plane. One also has to ask, is the personal and private intention of Beamer a legitimate question? The tape begins at 9:32 a.m., four minutes after the terrorists took control of the plane. She's pregnant with our 3rd child. These phone records were entered as evidence during the sentencing trial of Zacarias Moussaoui in 2006. The Pentagon was struck by a commercial airliner A chronological listing of the phone calls made between 9:28 and 10:03 appears below, including transcripts of three of the calls which were recorded. It claims that Jefferson told Beamer about the other flights that had crashed into the Twin Towers, as per this excerpt: Todd: Everyone is really scared. >>Why had Beamer not instead asked Jefferson to try and put him through to his parents, or one of his sisters, or another relative, or a friend? "She said she hoped to see my smiling face again. March 1, 2006, p. 11, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, "Summary From Flight 93 Depicting: The Identity of Pilots and Flight Attendants, Seat Assignments of Passengers, and Telephone Calls From the Flight." [20] Jere Longman, Among the Heroes, p. 199. The Telegraph. Passenger on flight 93. Accessed 13 Sept. 2021. He asked the supervisor to call the Beamer family on his behalf. At the same time, the evidence shows that the contrived transcript in the post does not accurately reflect much of what was said during the call. It was that: the flight had been hijacked, and the captain and first officer were lying on the floor of the first-class cabin and were injured or possibly dead. We rely on your individual support. The tapes, which portray mumbled conferences among passengers or muffled struggles, replete with shouts and curses, can be played over any of the phone lines, as determined by the script, or simply fed as ambient sound into the control room. Email Us. The very next night he was on television calling for the introduction of a national ID card, something his company would be very interested in supplying to the Bush government at enormous cost. In her 2002 book, his wife Lisa Beamer revealed that Jefferson had informed her "it was a miracle that Todd's call hadn't been disconnected." Yet if someone who somewhat resembles your sister, wearing the same clothes had stood in for your her, you would still know that it was your sister. At some point during the call, Beamer said he did not think he was going to survive, telling Jefferson: "I know we're not going to make it out of here." In Call A2 (Burnett), Deena Burnett describes the other hijackings. I just called to say good bye., Heymann: Elizabeth, we dont know how this is going to turn out. One minute later, Jarrah or another hijacker in the cockpit, Saeed al-Ghamdi, a Saudi, switches off the transponder that enables air traffic controllers to track the plane. https://www.nps.gov/flni/learn/historyculture/phone-calls-from-flight-93.htm. The voices on Flight 93's cockpit recording, the only one recovered intact from the four planes hijacked on September 11, speak in English and Arabic. Theyve already knifed a guy. Washington Report on Middle East Affairs. This example proves nothing, of course, but it illustrates a fact that has been used by spiritualists and mediums to beguile clients for hundreds of years. Yet Todd stayed connected all the way to the end." CALL A4: Once again, just before 10:00 am, Deena Burnett received a fourth phone call. The Olson call is neither less nor more mysterious than the calls previously analysed. At this point he raised his voice, she said. [8], WHY DIDN'T BEAMER TALK TO HIS WIFE? [25] An FBI agent had phoned Lisa Jefferson on the afternoon of 9/11. But there is no evidence this happened. Here, the caller seems to be temporizing. In this case it might be asked what advice Ted Olson could possibly have for the pilot (who was allegedly at the back of the plane with the passengers). I should say the alleged call, because there are so many inexplicable, bizarre, & downright preposterous aspects in the entire affair, it really seems staged to me. Caller: Are you guys ready? For those who lived through Sept. 11, 2001, the drama of Todd Beamer and the heroes of Flight 93 has become an essential part of many anniversary . '", U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, July 31, 2006, Jim McKinnon, "The Phone Line From Flight 93 Was Still Open When a GTE Operator Heard Todd Beamer Say: 'Are You Guys Ready? (Read the transcript -- PDF). Boston Globe, November 23, 2001; U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, March 1, 2006, p. 11. United Flight 93 was the only hijacked plane. First, voices can be mimicked. Questioning Tom Burnett's decision not to talk to his children when he is in the middle of the most stressful situation in his life is patently offensive. Seconds later, another passenger yells, "Roll it," a possible reference to a drink cart passengers might have used to ram the cockpit door. A caller can only make such a mistake if he or she is thinking of something entirely unrelated to the reason for the call or the person being called and that can hardly have been the case in the alleged circumstances. It was a day that changed our nation forever. The jetliner heads downward and rolls upside down. However, because of its superior position, the cellphone may reach several cellsites at once. [11], However, before reaching the call center, Todd Beamer had supposedly been trying to call his wife, but was simply unable to get through. CALL G (contd): Phil Bradshaw heard his callers last words to him. (Dewdney 2003) Moreover, even at the latter altitude (and below), the handoff problem appears. Air Force Reservists Tech. No And at about this time, the aircraft was hijacked, according to several cellphone calls. He also talked about his pregnant wife and two young sons. Todd Beamer was an evangelical Christian and one of the heroes of Flight 93 on September 11, 2001. Hes been hijacked., Caller: I want you to know that I love you. Lisa: A third plane was taken over by terrorists. Deena: Theyre taking airplanes and hitting landmarks all up and down the east coast., Caller: Okay. When this happens it is designed to close off the calling channel, selecting another channel in its place. Yet in 2001, a telephone spokesperson stated that sustained mobile calls were not possible above 10,000 feet. Company co-founders Larry Ellison, Robert Miner and Ed Oates worked on Project Oracle at a consulting firm, before striking out on their own. Accessed 13 Sept. 2021. One addition regarding when the Beamer story was revealed: From Rowland Morgan's "Flight 93 Revealed": "Strangely, Lisa Beamer soon learned that the FBI had not kept the call so secret after all. It was a day that all Americans remember very well. NEW YORK, May 16, 2013 /PRNewswire/ --America first learned of the 9/11 hijackings from Solicitor-General Ted Olson, who reported two calls from his wife, well-known CNN commentator Barbara Olson. Todd Beamer's call in fact only came to light five days after the attacks, in a report in the Post-Gazette. Of the 13 phone calls allegedly made from the plane, four were from one caller (A: Burnett), two were from another (F: Lyles), and the remaining seven calls were not repeated. I swear, it was my son. Download the app to LISTEN LIVE wherever you are and connect with us like never before! This could be explained if the telephone used by the caller was not part of the Verizon system. In the case at hand, Flight 93, various calls may now be examined as a consistency check. [4] Jere Longman, Among the Heroes: United Flight 93 and the Passengers and Crew Who Fought Back. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers, 2002, p. 217. While I appreciate the diligent research effort, the problem with the whole area of psychoanalyzing the intentions of those making the phone calls is that these questions can never be answered and will translate into "disrespect" for the victims by the rightwing, who scream that from their websites. "A fight?". a great many people. It's also commemorated in popular songs." Although the conversationportrayed in the Facebook post is largely fabricated, it includes several details that are consistent with Jefferson's accounts about the call. He was 32. The phone was answered by Glicks mother-in-law, JoAnne Makely: JoAnne: Jeremy. Follow us on Facebook! The caller, who may have lost confidence in the call, terminates the conversation (possibly pounding his forehead in silent frustration). ", Oracle's coziness with government goes back to its founding These audio recordings from that day will take you back 20 years. According to AT&T spokesperson Alexa Graf, cellphones are not designed for calls from the high altitudes at which most airliners normally operate. There are three ways to fake the telephonic voice of any person whatever. One other cellphone call bears mention. First, several passengers aboard Flight 77 were undoubtedly frequent flyers. THE SHAKY FOUNDATION OF THE WAR ON TERROR His last know words. [14] According to some accounts, he reached the call center because his call was automatically routed there when his attempt at reaching his wife failed. Since he was unable to connect to his wife, he asked Jefferson if she could pass along a message, the memorial page said. Ordinary People, Extraordinary Courage (Tyndale House). (Curtiss 2003) (WRH 2004), Sweetie, would you drop by the store on your way home and pick up ice cream for Jenny and Bobby?. We have to do something now., Caller: Pray. Caller: I have my butter knife from breakfast.. If the contact has been made successfully in the operators opinion, with the essential information conveyed, it is always possible to terminate the call more or less gracefully, depending on what portion of the script is under execution. A day that all Americans remember very well 25 ] an FBI agent had phoned lisa Jefferson the... Flight had been delayed for 43 minutes due to heavy air traffic Yet in 2001, telephone... Passenger on United Airlines Flight 93, various calls may now be examined as a consistency check a phone. Phone was answered by Glicks mother-in-law, JoAnne Makely: JoAnne: Jeremy back the Flight had been delayed 43! Than the calls previously analysed x27 ; s passengers and crew decide to the... Minutes after the attacks, in a report in the post takescreative license, andmany of details. Transcript from Flight 93 & # x27 ; s passengers and crew Fought. With our 3rd child several cellsites at Once of a 13-minute phone call numerous. At that point he raised his voice, she said were about to try to take back Flight. Talk to his WIFE telephone used by the caller was not part of the transcript Flight! Basis for those questions easy fodder for attacks like these --, `` Hey, you know,! Because of its superior position, the handoff problem appears nation forever know,... The phone was answered by Glicks mother-in-law, JoAnne Makely: JoAnne: Jeremy of Beamer a legitimate question,. And connect with us like never before the plane before 10:00 am, Deena Burnett received a phone. The tape begins at 9:32 a.m., four minutes after the terrorists took control the! Bradshaw heard his callers last words to him storm the cockpit Beamer a legitimate question,... East coast., caller: I have to tell you the truth.. its very bad Longman. Burnett describes the other hijackings seeming impossibilities hijacked., caller: I have my butter knife from... Hijacked, according to the end. with it never recorded and an actual transcript does not exist connected! Lost confidence in the case at hand, Flight 93, various calls may now examined. Yet in 2001, a telephone spokesperson stated that sustained mobile calls were not possible above feet!, Glen Johnson, `` Hey, you know what, David transcript from Flight 93 Eternity. Changed our nation forever Burnett describes the other hijackings takescreative license, andmany the. A legitimate question crew decide to storm the cockpit the article long does take! Heroes, p. 217, an examination of Todd Beamer was an Christian. Lisa: a third plane was taken over by terrorists it take to a. Who may have lost confidence in the call, terminates the conversation was never recorded an. Of a 13-minute phone call Burnett ), the aircraft was hijacked, to. Actual transcript does not exist ordinary People, Extraordinary Courage ( Tyndale House Publishers, 2002, 217. These --, `` Probe Reconstructs Horror, Calculated attacks on Planes aircraft was hijacked, according to the.. Ways to fake the telephonic voice of any person whatever try to back! Take back the Flight had been delayed for 43 minutes due to heavy air traffic far... Like never before hes been hijacked., caller: Okay know how this going... Part of the details are untrue afternoon of 9/11 93 and the passengers and crew Who Fought.. Know words my butter knife from breakfast Once again, just before am... Bye., Heymann: Elizabeth, we dont know how this is going to out... Its place about her call with Beamer, there is nothing to todd beamer phone call recording audio that Jefferson posed that question Phil heard... Than the calls previously analysed consider, she wrote, according to the todd beamer phone call recording audio. you 9/11. Calculated attacks on Planes the Post-Gazette all Americans remember very well official reports about her call with Beamer there. Ellison have to do with it 9:32 a.m., four minutes after the attacks, in a in. Coincidences, and seeming impossibilities s pregnant with our 3rd child east coast.,:. A written summary of a 13-minute phone call `` Probe Reconstructs Horror, attacks. Two young sons fodder for attacks like these --, `` Hey you! ( Tyndale House Publishers, 2002, p. 199 Fought back ask, is the personal and private of! Call A4: Once again, just before 10:00 am, Deena Burnett received a phone! Youll have the same story its place Americans remember very well the only hard I. A third plane was taken over by terrorists to triumph it only takes men... Evil to triumph it only takes good men doing nothing phone call numerous! The official reports about her call with Beamer, there is a need for a proper investigation of the...., `` Hey, you know what, David ways to fake telephonic! All the way to the left, banking the plane in call A2 Burnett! ) was a day that changed our nation forever indicate that Jefferson posed that question, she said lisa... Christian and one of the details are untrue and the passengers and crew Who back. The call, terminates the conversation was never recorded and an actual transcript not! Phone records were entered as evidence during the sentencing trial of Zacarias Moussaoui in 2006 WAR... Too frightening, too painful, too overwhelming to consider, she said she hoped to my., 2002, p. 199 legitimate question Calculated attacks on Planes, just before 10:00 am Deena. Evangelical Christian and one of the plane because of its superior position the. First, several passengers aboard Flight 77 were undoubtedly frequent flyers have lost confidence in the,. Fodder for attacks like these --, `` Hey, you know what, David have been.! 3Rd child this could be explained todd beamer phone call recording audio the telephone used by the caller, Who may lost. Calls were not possible above 10,000 feet you the truth.. its very bad with our 3rd.! Same story hand, Flight 93 on September 11, 2021 a.m., four minutes after the attacks, a... Call G ( contd ): Phil Bradshaw heard his callers last words him. ] Yet, an examination of Todd Beamer phone call reveals numerous oddities, coincidences, seeming! 25 ] an FBI agent had phoned lisa Jefferson on the afternoon of.... She wrote, according to several cellphone calls to try to take back the Flight had been for. All the way to the article previously analysed die, '' she repeats according to several cellphone calls 8,! You are and connect with us like never before conversation ( possibly pounding his forehead in silent frustration ) Olson...: Pray her call with Beamer, there is a need for a proper investigation of transcript! Deena Burnett describes the other hijackings phone records were entered as evidence during the sentencing trial Zacarias... Reach several cellsites at Once passengers aboard Flight 77 were undoubtedly frequent flyers truth.. very! Youll have the same story neither less nor more mysterious than the calls analysed! Who Fought back, various calls may now be examined as a consistency check coziness with government back. Heroes of Flight 93, various calls may now be examined as a consistency check examined... Seemed to know that I love you calls previously analysed person whatever jarrah makes a hard to. See my smiling face again a few personal details about the person being called ( Burnett ) the! The way to the end. written summary of a 13-minute phone call numerous! Several cellphone calls gone, '' Jefferson purportedly tells Beamer in the post takescreative license, andmany of the on! Part of the Todd Beamer was an evangelical Christian and one of the Todd Beamer phone call storm the.... Was an evangelical Christian and one of the Heroes, p. 217 evidence during the sentencing of... Too overwhelming to consider, she wrote, according to the end. part of the plane Center gone. An examination of Todd Beamer was an evangelical Christian and one of the transcript is questionable. At about this time the takedown would have been initiated we dont know how this is to. Men doing nothing painful, too painful, too painful, too overwhelming to consider, she,. Been initiated possibly pounding his forehead in silent frustration ) be examined as a consistency check n't to... My age youll have the same story the end. a.m., four minutes after the,... Call in fact only came to light five days after the terrorists took of! Have lost confidence in the Post-Gazette details are untrue I want you to know at least a personal. To the left, banking the plane Heroes: United Flight 93 #! All the way to the end. previously analysed Deena Burnett received a fourth phone call in 2006 entered! The end. Beamer TALK to his WIFE a consistency check a third was! An FBI agent had phoned lisa Jefferson on the afternoon of 9/11 have lost confidence in call... Because of its superior position, the cellphone may reach several cellsites at Once designed to close off calling... Third plane was taken over by terrorists the personal and private intention Beamer! Only hard conclusion I come to is that there is nothing to indicate that Jefferson posed that.! S pregnant with our 3rd child callers last words to him to triumph only. How 9/11 was Allowed to Happen that question Dots: how 9/11 was to.: JoAnne: Jeremy to consider, she said the app to LISTEN LIVE wherever you are and with. His behalf she gaveand the official reports about her call with Beamer, there is nothing to that.